As the end of another school year approaches, all over the country parents and graduating high school seniors are having discussions from calm to passionate about what comes next. Some students know exactly what they want to do next while others are not so sure.
This dilemma is not exclusive to those students whose high school transcripts and test scores tell a story of limited opportunities and minimal options. Even among students who are actually prepared for the academic rigors of college there is often indecision. The wavering should be expected. Graduating from high school and being asked to decide what to do with the rest of your life – particularly when you have so few life experiences to draw from – is not only frightening it’s ridiculously unfair.
THREE CHOICES
Prior to the end of my sophomore year in high school, my father had the talk with me. No, we didn’t talk about the birds and the bees. Nor did we have the talk African American parents are having with their children today about the police. Thank heavens, we had those conversations long before my sophomore year in high school. Rather, my father and I had the talk – the talk about my options.
I remember the conversation like it happened yesterday. While standing in the kitchen, my dad said these words to me “you know in two years you have to do something”. I looked at my father quizzically, wondering what in the world he was talking about this time. You see my father had a habit of starting conversations out of thin air.
“No dad”, I said, “what do I have to do?” With an unsympathetic look and a resolve in his voice, my father spoke these words, “you have to get a job and move, join the service and move, or go to college”. I stood silently which was odd for me because like most teenagers it was my custom to have a retort for everything. However, on this occasion, I could not speak. At that moment, my life flashed before me and it was desperately bleak.
STARING INTO THE ABYSS
Soon after informing me of my three choices, my father left the kitchen. I continued to stand while staring into the abyss. None of the three choices felt right.
The first choice was identical. I had a job already. In fact, I had been working since fifth grade and I realized right around the sixth grade that working all day everyday was overrated. The additional requirement of moving away from my mom was cruel and unusual punishment.
The second choice was inconceivable. My father had served during the 1960s and spoke critically about the racial conditions in the military. Based on my father’s disposition and the fact that I grew up in segregated Gary, Indiana the idea of living some place where I would be a marginalized minority and have to take orders from people like my father was unimaginable.
The third choice seemed unlikely. I was a borderline average to poor student. My transcript from the first two years of high school were littered with “Cs”. Although, I didn’t know much about the college admission process back then I knew enough to know that I wasn’t “college material”.
MAKE THE BEST OF A BAD SITUATION
Most of you know my story. I was able to earn a few vowels to go along with all those consonants and managed to get admitted to college. What you may not know is that going to college was not my dream scenario it was simply my way of making the best out of a bad situation. As a seventeen year old, who had lived in one city his entire life and had only once boarded a plane (from Chicago to St. Louis), I could not imagine a life more than the one I was living.
Proof of my lack of vision played out in my college choices. All of the colleges where I applied were chosen based on the experiences and visions of others. I applied to Purdue University because all the smart kids in my school were applying there. I applied to Fisk University because the most accomplished man that I knew personally was an alum. I applied to Butler University because my uncle lived in Indianapolis and my mom said that he could drive me home on weekends.
If my naivety and lack of preparation to make the most important decision in my life were not obvious enough, the process for selecting a major makes it clearer. In large part, I chose accounting as a major because my mom, who worked for a mental health institution, was employed as an Accounts Receivable Clerk. I also chose accounting as a major because I assumed accounting was mostly math. Boy was I ever wrong.
Talk about dazed and confused. Being given only three choices – all of which seemed to seal my fate – left me mentally exhausted and emotionally fatigued. Actually, I could have been a patient at my mom’s place of employment. At the very least, I sure could have used some professional counseling; perhaps a life coach.
In hindsight there are probably at least a thousand other things I should have considered before deciding to major in accounting or where to go to college. I liked math but I didn’t love math. I had no clue what it meant to be an accounting major or what it meant to work as an accountant. Nor did I know that by attending Butler I would instantaneously become a marginalized minority who would experience many of the same racial inequities I thought I would avoid by not enlisting in the military.
TAKE A GAP YEAR
Unfortunately for me there were only three choices: move out, take orders from another drill sergeant or go to college. If I knew what I know now chances are that I would have chosen something other than Butler University, accounting and occasional rides home on weekends with my uncle.
Today, I would have most likely done what my son did – take a gap year. According to the American Gap Association, “A gap year is a structured period of time when students take a break from formal education to increase self-awareness, challenge comfort zones, and experiment with possible careers.”
Many of our best and most respected colleges and universities encourage students to take a gap year. For example, Harvard “encourages admitted students to defer enrollment for one year to travel, pursue a special project or activity, work, or spend time in another meaningful way…”
A GAP YEAR MAKES SENSE
If you are on the precipitous of having the talk with your child – alerting them of their three options –you might want to give them a fourth option. If my story isn’t a compelling enough reason to consider a gap year give some thought to the following:
- Better Performance – Studies show that students who take a gap year generally perform better than their peers who go directly from high school to college. Academic Burnout is real. Per the Council of the Great City Schools, students take an average of 113 standardized tests between pre-K and 12th grade. I don’t know about you but I need a gap year just thinking about all those tests.
- Leaving Never Never Land – Americans work more than any other industrialized nation. The average person spends 90,000 hours at work over their lifetime, takes only 57 percent of their vacation days and when taking a vacation 25 percent of workers respond to work related phone calls and emails. With all the hours Americans work, when exactly are children supposed to have time for self-discovery and personal enrichment?
- Dying to Work – A 2013 study conducted by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) reports that the U.S ranks 26th in life expectancy which is also one year behind the international average. Not only are we dying early but we are working jobs that the majority of us hate. According to the 2013 Conference Board Job Satisfaction survey, only 47.7 percent of workers are satisfied with their jobs. Given the fact that it appears our children are going to die sooner than later and while they are living they are going to work at jobs they hate, shouldn’t we give a gap year some real consideration?
NO CELEBRITY ENDORSEMENT
It is not my intent to tell you that you should allow your child to take a gap year. The educational and career path you and your child select is a personal decision that should be made with great reflection. I simply wanted to make you aware of an option my father never presented to me.
Adulthood and the accompanying adult responsibilities last a lifetime. Childhood, on the other hand, lasts a mere eighteen years if you are lucky. So rather than rush into a decision that might impact the rest of your child’s life, a gap year might be a perfect transition between childhood and adulthood; indecision and certainty; and time and money wasted and time and money well spent.
How much would you enjoy a gap year from adulthood? What do you think of the gap year concept?
Ken Carfagno says
Nathaniel, it’s funny you wrote about this. My wife just shared another blog post on the “gap year”. Here’s the link — http://www.artofmanliness.com/2009/06/22/the-benefits-of-a-gap-year/ I didn’t realize that it was written five years ago. Anyway, I like your explanation better. You are a very good writer. My take is simple – Do it! I wish I would have. I did a gap month after college to Europe (backpacking & Eurorail). I talk about the impact of those 30 days more today than I do of my entire 4 1/2 years at Penn State for mechanical engineering. Had I taken a “gap year” instead, I may just have pursued the dream that I came full circle to… ten years later 🙂
RSPAdmin says
Good day Ken: As always thanks for taking time to read our blog. I know that there are lots of other things you could be doing with your time. I am so grateful that you choose to spend some of your time with us. Moreover, thanks for sharing the link and your story. Backpacking through Europe sounds like an awesome experience and opportunity. Would I be correct to assume that you are not a practicing engineer today? I am intrigued by where you are in your life and where you started especially considering that my son is an engineering major. Thanks again.
Ken Carfagno says
Nathaniel, I loved engineering for 2 years and then burnt out. After 5 1/2 uears, I went from top guy to fired due to losing my passion and being a moron. Then we started a cleaning company which was rough for a while but God pulled us through. In the last 5 years I have enjoyed a flexible work schedule as an entrepreneur to he with my wife and 4 kids. And I have been able to apply the skills of engineering toward my passion of writing books for fathers & sons. You don’t need my advice, he’s got you as a dad 🙂 but I’d he glad to talk to him if he wants.
RSPAdmin says
Ken for the first time, I think you might be wrong! 🙂 Yes, my son has me but I actually believe that it takes a village to raise a child. I don’t know anything about engineering. I was in no way smart enough to do what you did and what he is striving to do. So I would be indebted to you if and when he needed someone to talk to that you would be willing to speak with him.
On another note, congrats on your entrepreneurial success and being present for your family.That’s good stuff! Where can I find your books? I would love to read them and share them with others.
Ken Carfagno says
Too funny! I’m wrong all the time. Hopefully I can be on the positive side of the (+/-) stat. Friend me on FB or LinkedIn! We can chat offline. In the meantime, I’ll keep reading the Word Smith &)